Book demo

Workforce Management | 10 Software Solutions | Providers

Staff planning: 10 Software Solutions at a Glance

Staff Planning Providers

If you’ve ever tried to tame shift scheduling for a mid-sized company with 150 employees, three different collective bargaining agreements, last-minute sick calls and everyone’s individual vacation wishes in an Excel sheet, you know: this isn’t a job, it’s the endgame.

This is exactly where Workforce Management (WFM) and digital staff planning step in. But the software market makes orientation increasingly difficult. There simply isn’t a one-size-fits-all solution for every company; however, the wide range of vendors gives you the chance to find a produ

Inhalt

The basics of staff planning: How should modern HR-software perform today.

Before the actual analysis, we’ll briefly cover the theoretical basics. Anyone looking for personnel scheduling software quickly realizes: professional are long more than just digital calendars. These are complex systems that ideally consist of the following six building blocks: 

young women
  • Demand determination & forecasting: The software analyzes historical data such as revenue or customer traffic and uses AI to forecast the exact staffing needs for specific periods.  
  • Staff planning: As a core function, the system automatically assigns shifts considering qualifications, working-time accounts and ergonomic criteria.  
  • Digital time tracking & access control: Recording is done via app, web or terminal. The system compares actual times directly with the planned schedule and logs deviations immediately.  
  • Absence & vacation management: Vacation and absence requests are handled through digital workflows, which automatically update the planning matrix in the background.  
  • Employee integration (Self Rostering & ESS): Employees can swap shifts via app, set preferences or apply for open shifts, which increases employee autonomy.  
  • Legal certainty & compliance: The system checks legal requirements (Working Hours Act — ArbZG), break rules and collective agreements (e.g., TVöD, AVR) already during planning and prevents violations. 

ArbZG on your back: Why Excel is a legal risk

Ever since the Federal Labour Court (BAG) ruling on systematic working-time recording, paper-based systems have become legally very risky. The German Working Hours Act (ArbZG) allows no mistakes. Anyone who exceeds the maximum daily working time of 10 hours or falls short of the statutory rest period of 11 hours (§ 5 ArbZG) risks substantial penalties. Any high-quality scheduling software checks these rules in real time. If you plan incorrectly by accident, the system will block the entry before something goes wrong. 

 

 

Comparison matrix in the market overview

The following overview summarizes the key criteria and functional scope of the vendors. The matrix shows at a glance which systems are aimed at which company profiles and illustrates the differences in a practical comparison of workforce-management software in Germany. 

Criterion / Function  plano WFM  ATOSS  GFOS  ISGUS  Quinyx  INFORM  ASTRUM IT  Shiftbase  Shyft-plan  Aplano 
Target Group  SMB to Enterprise  Enterprise / Corporate  Mid-market / Industry  Mid-market  Mid-market to Enterprise  Large Corporates / Logistics  SMB to Mid-market  Small Businesses / SMB  Mid-market / Industry  Small Businesses / SMB 
Real-Time Validation (Labor Law / Tariff)  Yes (Extremely deep)  Yes (Extremely deep)  Yes  Yes  Yes  Yes  Basic  Basic  Yes  Basic 
AI-Powered Forecasting  Yes  Yes  Yes  No  Yes  Yes  No  No  Basic  No 
Self-Rostering / App  Yes  Yes  Yes  Yes  Yes  Yes  Basic  Yes  Yes  Yes 
Proprietary Hardware Terminals  No (Interfaces)  Yes  Yes  Yes  No  No  No  No  No  No 

Shift scheduling software. The most important systems in detail

1.plano

plano plano WFM focuses as an all-in-one solution on planning staffing needs precisely while also taking employee wishes into account. 

  • Focus: Mid-sized to large companies, call centers, retail and healthcare, aiming to combine economic efficiency and employee satisfaction. 
  • Strengths: Extremely precise demand calculation based on historical business data. The software handles complex, multi-shift working-time models and offers seamless, legally secure time recording. Integrated skills management prevents mis-scheduling for specialized tasks. 
  • Standout feature: Extended request book with exchange marketplace. In the app, employees can not only submit time-off requests but also swap shifts among themselves fully automatically under defined fairness rules—without manual planner intervention. 

2. ATOSS

The ATOSS Staff Efficiency Suite is a legacy and heavyweight in the European enterprise market. 

  • Focus: DAX corporations, large enterprises, complex structures in healthcare and large retail. 
  • Strengths: Unbeatable depth in strategic capacity planning and handling huge data volumes. The system maps global collective agreements, country-specific laws and complex works agreements flawlessly. It provides powerful analytics tools for HR forecasts. 
  • Standout feature: Automatic schedule creation (schedules with one click). A highly developed AI algorithm optimizes plans for tens of thousands of employees at once. It reconciles labor laws, collective agreements, qualifications, costs and employee preferences in seconds. 

3. GFOS

Under the brand gfos this experienced vendor delivers a modular system deeply rooted in the domestic economy. 

  • Focus: Upper mid-sized companies and manufacturing industry. 
  • Strengths: Brilliant integration with shop-floor data collection (BDE) and machine data collection (MDE). Staff planning is combined with real machine run-times. The system is modular and grows flexibly with company needs. 
  • Standout feature: Real-time synchronization with production. If a production machine fails unexpectedly or a job completes faster, gfos immediately adjusts staffing needs on the affected lines and suggests changes. 

4. ISGUS

ISGUS brings the ZEUS solution: an interesting combination of software with in-house hardware. 

  • Focus: Mid-sized companies, manufacturing and the public sector. 
  • Strengths: If you want physical time-recording terminals and access control for factory gates from a single source, this is the right choice. The software performs well in public sector workflows (TVöD) and offers reliable processes for absences and vacation requests. 
  • Standout feature: Hardware-software symbiosis. The in-house IT terminals act as kiosk systems. Employees without a PC workplace can see their schedules, request vacation and check time accounts directly at the gate via touchscreen. 

5. Quinyx

Quinyx from Sweden is a fully cloud-native platform that follows a strict “mobile first” approach. 

  • Focus: Retail chains, quick-service restaurants, logistics – industries with a large deskless workforce. 
  • Strengths: The employee app is excellent in terms of UI/UX. Shift distribution and AI forecasts run extremely smoothly. The system drastically reduces communication loops and increases employee retention through transparent, mobile processes. 
  • Standout feature: AI-driven sales and demand forecasting. Quinyx analyzes weather data, historical sales and events to predict exact staffing needs in retail or hospitality down to 15-minute intervals. 

6. INFORM

Here mathematics rules. INFORM uses advanced operations-research algorithms to optimize logistics chains. 

  • Focus: Airports (aviation), massive logistics centers and ports. 
  • Strengths: Unmatched when it comes to replanning thousands of employees by the minute in the face of unpredictable events. The system handles extreme mathematical complexity and protects critical infrastructure against staff shortages. 
  • Standout feature: Real-time disruption management. For sudden events (e.g., severe weather at an airport or flight delays) the system computes the optimal redeployment of personnel across the airfield in real time to minimize delays. 

7. ASTRUM IT

ASTRUM IT Erlangen-based ASTRUM IT is a classic IT project house that builds highly customized solutions. 

  • Focus: Transport, logistics, medical technology and IT service providers. 
  • Strengths: Extremely high data security standards (Made in Germany) and great flexibility for individual requirements. No off-the-shelf standard software, but tailor-made adaptation to historically grown, highly specific company processes. 
  • Standout feature: Maximum customization depth. ASTRUM IT develops proprietary interfaces and individual software modules for companies whose needs cannot be met by any standard market software.

8. Shiftbase 

Shiftbase shifts down a few gears and focuses fully on minimalism and simplicity. 

  • Focus: Small businesses, startups, hospitality and local retail. 
  • Strengths: Drag-and-drop shift planning that you can use without training. Transparent pricing, ready to go immediately. It offers uncomplicated time tracking via app, web or tablet terminal directly in the store and quick payroll preparation. 
  • Standout feature: Real-time personnel cost control while planning. When creating the schedule with drag-and-drop, Shiftbase shows the expected personnel costs and percentage of revenue live, so the budget is never exceeded unnoticed. 

9. Shyftplan

Shyftplan is fully committed to automated shift planning for the modern workplace. 

  • Focus: Automotive industry, large bakeries and medium-sized manufacturing businesses. 
  • Strengths: Massive relief for planners through automation. The system breaks up rigid shift systems and makes industrial planning flexible without violating strict legal and collective-agreement requirements. 
  • Standout feature: The “Shyft Score.” An intelligent algorithm evaluates open shifts and assigns them automatically with one click to the workforce. It balances fairness, working-time accounts, qualifications and legal rest periods simultaneously. 

10. Aplano

Modern, fresh, no frills: Aplano is a young tool with a visually contemporary design that secured a solid place in our WFM overview. 

  • Focus: SMEs, agencies, modern care facilities and hospitality. 
  • Strengths: Extremely intuitive UI, very fair price-performance ratio and a sharp integrated vacation planner. Admin and employee onboarding time is almost zero, which greatly increases team acceptance. 
  • Standout feature: Integrated in-app messenger tied to shifts. Communication and scheduling are merged. Employees can discuss questions about specific shifts directly in the app within the relevant shift thread without resorting to external messengers (like WhatsApp). 

Branches  Recommended WFM vendors 
Retail  plano, ATOSS, Quinyx  
Contact Center   pPlano, ATOSS  
Healthcare  plano,  ATOSS,  Aplano  
Logistics / production / industry  GFOS, INFORM,  Astrum IT,  Shyftplan, plano 
Public sector  plano, ISGUS,  Astrum IT  
Aviation   INFORM, plano 
Hospitality / hotels  Quinyx, Shiftbase  

Conclusion

Workforce Management Software is an indispensable tool for companies that want to make their shift scheduling efficient, legally compliant and employee oriented. The market offers a wide range of solutions that differ significantly in target group, functionality and complexity. 

Choosing the right software strongly depends on company size, industry focus and requirements for automation, forecasting and compliance. Modern staff planning goes far beyond simple rosters and combines intelligent planning, digital time tracking and employee integration – factors that are crucial to business success in times of skilled labor shortages and rising legal demands. The right Workforce Management Software relieves HR and planners, ensures satisfied employees and helps avoid legal risks. An honest comparison like this is therefore indispensable to find the tool that fits your company’s individual needs. 

DEMO BUCHEN

Would you like to learn more about workforce management?

For more information, please click here:

→ Workforce Management from plano

Carolin Holstein, Marketing & PR, plano solutions gmbh

Carolin Holstein

Marketing & PR

Carolin Holstein manages the editorial content of this blog and works in the Marketing/PR field. With her clear, audience-oriented language, she presents complex topics in a comprehensible and practical manner. Through her regular creation of editorial content, she has built extensive knowledge in workforce management, combining marketing expertise with professional depth.

We’re Here for You

Have questions about our products?
We’re here to help.
Frau macht ein Herz mit ihren Händen

Great to have you here

Work with us to find the best solution for your company too.
Make an appointment now for a free, no-obligation product demo.

Great that you want to meet us

Register now for our roadshow in your area.

Great that you want to meet us

Register now for the plano Campus. Please register each participant individually and with their own email address!

Great to have you here

Work with us to find the best solution for your company too.
Make an appointment now for a free, no-obligation product demo.

"*" indicates required fields

This field is for validation purposes and should be left unchanged.
Name*
E-Mail*

Please fill in all fields marked with * before submitting the form.